Petco Text Logo
Petco Pet Logo

Petco Pet Store in Bay Shore

1851 Sunrise Hwy
Bay Shore NY, 11706
Get Directions
Explore Top Deals & SavingsShop Now

Our Services

Welcome to your Petco in Bay Shore, NY

Petco on Sunrise Highway (NY-27) in Bay Shore serves pet parents from West Islip, Brentwood, Central Islip, East Islip, Islip, North Babylon, and Brightwaters at 1851 Sunrise Hwy. The store carries a wide selection of dog food and cat food alongside supplies for every kind of pet, and in-house services include dog grooming, dog training classes, veterinary care, and a full aquatics department. This Petco is part of The Market at Bay Shore, so you can handle a full round of errands without an extra trip. Petco Love partners with local shelters to help pets find homes, and this store is proud to be part of that network in Bay Shore. Good pets deserve good neighbors.
Shop Now

Frequently Asked Questions

Petco Pet Store in Bay Shore, NY Reviews

What Customers Say

Helpful Staff

Many customers describe the staff as friendly, knowledgeable, professional, and willing to go beyond expectations to help with products, pets, and purchases.

Product Selection

Customers frequently praise the broad variety of food, animals, aquarium supplies, and pet products, with many saying they can usually find what they need.

Service Consistency

Staff service is often praised, but several customers report rude or unhelpful interactions, inconsistent appointment handling, and unclear communication about policies or requirements.

Grooming Experiences

Grooming experiences vary. Some customers praise gentle, attentive care and successful grooming, while others report poor cuts, pet distress, injuries, or unprofessional handling.

Pricing Issues

Some customers find prices high or report confusing discounts, coupon limitations, and differences between advertised online prices and in-store or shipped prices.

Summarized with AI

Woman with her dog & cat sitting on the floor while shopping at Petco on her phone.

Download our App

App storeGoogle store